China and our force structure

M1A1 Abrams heavy tanks with Abrams Integrated Management System and the new Tank Urban Survivability Kit in Iraq.

The Challenge From China

Mark Helprin in the Wall Street Journal:

As we content ourselves with the fallacy that never again shall we have to fight large, technological opponents, China is transforming its forces into a full-spectrum military capable of major operations and remote power projection. Eventually the twain shall meet.

Obviously, today's war requires us to transform our military into one capable of fighting and winning low-intensity campaigns against low-tech enemies and then following up with a long period of stability operations. But while we need to do this, we need to be careful not to over-compensate.

One thing I've been thinking about is the idea that maybe the National Guard combat units remained focused almost exclusively on traditional army-on-army tactics and equipped with the heavies to fight and win such wars while the active duty Army is morphed over time to face current situations.

This would allow more stable training and equipping of the Guard, hopefully making them better able to be used quickly in the event things go south. The active Army, while retaining a good portion of its big war capability, could be tweaked as things change. Full-time troops could more easily train for new missions and equipment than Guard troops, and they could do so with the assurance that sufficient heavy divisions are available if needed.

This would have the added effect of removing many Guard units from the rotation of deployments to the campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan, but I think in the long run that's a benefit. You'd probably have to grow the active Army a bit more, but, again, that's long overdue in any event.

Thoughts?

Show us your tats
Kyle Cassidy is working on a new book of veterans tattoos called "War Paint". You can see some of it on his website at www.kylecassidy.com/warpaint. At the moment, he's specifically looking for WWII and Korean war vets with military tats. If you work with a VFW post or know...[READ]

Not moving to Fargo, after all
Wife guilty of draining guardsman’s funds A jury has convicted a woman of draining her husband’s investment accounts while he was serving in Iraq with the Minnesota National Guard... John Kieser gave his wife “power of attorney,” before he left but said he intended her to use it only if...[READ]

House to House (of Representatives)
Cadillac Light: SSG David Bellavia is running for congress in New York State. Bellavia served in the First Infantry Division for six years. He has been recommended for the Medal of Honor and has been nominated for the Distinguished Service Cross. He wrote a book about his experience in...[READ]

Complusory Service
Jay Tea on Drafty Reasoning: I find myself wondering if those who are pushing for the return of the draft are willing to say that it was a mistake to abolish it in the first place over 30 years ago, and those who fought -- and won -- to do...[READ]

Recruiting
Tough times for today’s recruiters The military services face the toughest recruiting environment in a generation, as the most recent data shows interest in military service at its lowest level in more than 25 years. Internal Defense Department surveys tracking the opinions of potential recruits — mostly young men ages...[READ]

Numbers
Strategy Page: Five years of fighting in Iraq has killed 4,000 American troops. The first five years of fighting in Vietnam (1965-69) killed 40,258...If the casualty rates [per number of troops deployed] were the same in Iraq, there should have been 13,747 dead so far. Let's not forget that common...[READ]

MN Protest
MichaelMoore.com featured this on their front page a couple of days ago: Mission Accomplished! Hundreds of Minnesota students rally, shut down military recruitment stations, 16 arrested It eventually links to this story in the MInnesota Daily: More than 200 students rally on campus against Iraq War, Sixteen people were...[READ]

Hillary's sniper rifle
I haven't even bothered posting on the whole "I remember landing under sniper fire" thing because A) I guess I don't know that it really matters all that much and B) It's unbridled jackassery. But a few new pieces of evidence have surfaced that I probably ought to point out....[READ]

'An onslaught of attack'
Court: Michael Moore did not defame Iraq vet A federal appeals court has ruled filmmaker Michael Moore did not defame an Iraq war veteran when Moore used a clip from a television interview without his permission in the anti-war documentary “Fahrenheit 9/11.” Moore says he makes "movies that point out...[READ]

Cycling 4 Children '08
2008 Equal Parenting Bike Trek - 758 Miles - Lansing Michigan to Washington, D.C. Five Michigan fathers will pedal their bicycles 758 miles from Lansing, MI to Washington, D.C. Robb MacKenzie - Upper Penninsula of Michigan - US EPBT Founder - 2007 cyclist Robert Pedersen - West Michigan -...[READ]

March 23: Two Holidays for the Price of One this year
Rachel Lucas, whose boyfriend is leaving to deploy to Iraq: I hereby declare March 23 as Punch A Hippie In The Nuts Day. All you have to do to celebrate it is find a hippie, ask him how he feels about the military, and if he says anything other than...[READ]

'You can't tell me that everybody didn't pray'
Faith in the Foxhole: How a soldier embraced his faith amidst the chaos of war This is the cover story in this month's Faith Grand Rapids magazine. Though Ed Czyzyk was a Marine and not a soldier, it's a great look at a local guy who served in World War...[READ]

The Key Statistic
Got this note in my inbox from the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America (IAVA): This week marks the fifth anniversary of the war in Iraq, but you might not have seen much about it on TV recently. Just 3% of the news in February was dedicated to the war...[READ]

Tough Spring?
Ex-Fort Lewis chief predicts tough spring for U.S. troops in Iraq The experience in Mosul offers a cautionary note as the U.S. military nears the fifth anniversary of the Iraq war amid a drawdown of American troops. "Al-Qaida realizes that this is an area they want to retain, and...[READ]

Recruiting station bombed
I hadn't looked at headlines this morning and only saw this just now: Police probe cyclist link in Times Square blast No injuries in pre-dawn attack on military recruiting station Bombing for peace. Or enemies....[READ]

I'd like to see the answer to this question
To improve retention, officials study why acquisition employees leave More than 80 percent of the 3,400 acquisition employees who quit in fiscal 2006 were not yet eligible to retire, and officials want to know why they left. The Federal Acquisition Institute will begin tracking where such employees go when they...[READ]

Knows the military
I don't understand. Why is Hillary running ads for the McCain campaign? Also, recall that in 2004 Hillary wondered why no one had sent the Clintons a thank-you note for building the military that performed so well in Iraq and Afghanistan. ...[READ]

Obama needs a lesson in military history
If he hopes to accomplish more than Bush, Obama needs better advisers Politicians rely heavily, on almost every subject, on advisors to get them educated and keep them current. And nobody really expects Obama or Clinton or even McCain, who was a Navy aviator, to know anything about ground combat....[READ]

12 months
Army plans to cut length of combat tours in Iraq LA Times: Moving to relieve strain on troops, the Army plans to reduce the length of combat tours from 15 months to one year after the troop buildup in Iraq winds down this summer, top officials told Congress on Tuesday....[READ]